PSY 452 Topic 2 Article Critique Experimental Design

You are currently viewing PSY 452 Topic 2 Article Critique Experimental Design

Composition Notices Experimental Design

Throughout this study, two main types of exploration models have assessed a factorial design as well as a two-group model. Each one of these models has a common theme in that they’re all about gestation. The factorial armature is concerned with motherly care gests in mice if the glucocorticoid receptor has an inheritable effect. The alternate study used a two-group style to determine the functional differences between women who had postpartum depression and those who did not.

Factorial Design

The experimenters were suitable to prize the responses of pregnant mice with the glucocorticoid receptor (GR) anomaly and pregnant mice without the GR anomaly, as well as how their habits are impacted, using a factorial design (Chourbaji et al., 2011). The mice were divided into two groups, Group A and Group B, for several days after birth, and the experimenters discovered a significant difference in motherly care conduct between the two groups. Group A mice showed an enhancement in motherly care exertion, with maters fixing, snuggling, and feeding their pups more constantly. Second, Group B was discovered to be more careless, flaunting further hostility and spending lots of time from outside the nest, allowing little room for the doggy’s nutrition( Chourbaji et al., 2011).

Crucial Goods Variables

PSY 452 Topic 2 Article Critique Experimental Design

The independent variables in this factorial design are the two different groups of mice, Group A and Group B; each one of these sets contained mice both with and without GR anomaly. The dependent variable is its mama mice’s motherly care after appearance. The investigators were looking for and seeing signs of motherly treatment, similar as drawing, rubbing, eating, and conserving their nests, as well as their exertion within and outside their nest and how the mama mice handled their babies (Chourbaji et al., 2011).

Confounding variables were used in this study, one of whom was lovemaking, which had been fulfilled by placing two women mice into the men’s pen. This system was problematic at best since it was reported that maybe the parentage sessions were ineffective, climaxing in detention in getting sufficiently pregnant mice for data collection. Experimenters were suitable to calculate the crucial goods, or the conduct of each independent variable, using this factorial design.

PSY 452 Topic 2 Article Critique Experimental Design

They did so by looking at the connections and shifts in the independent variables as a function of the situations of another independent variable. The GR genotype didn’t show a variation in motherly care gests when experimenters assessed the impact of pressure on the three groups of guests (Chourbaji et al., 2011). Group A expended slightly further time communicating formative material care gests to their pups, whereas Group B had further outside the nest with tone- care and tie.

Two-Group Design

The study examines the functional differences between women, either with or without postpartum depression, using a two-group layout (PPD). The screen scale was used to measure the signs and symptoms of each of the involved women, who were around six and twenty- six weeks postpartum (Posmontier, 2008). The dataset for the two groups was collected over the course of two thirty-nanosecond ages, one week separately. Individualities who were estimated during the first phase were issued the MINI29 to see if they had PPD, and those who were estimated in the alternate run were issued the PDSS and force of Functional Status After Childbirth (IFSAC) to help with bracket, soberness, and position of functionality (Posmontier, 2008).

Variables/Main Goods

PSY 452 Topic 2 Article Critique Experimental Design

People who are suffering from Postpartum depression are its independent variables in this analysis, with the degree of performance in the women serving as the dependent variables. Household habits, ménage care, and social and particular functioning are exemplifications of functional situations that experimenters were trying to examine. Race, support system, artistic-fiscal sustainability, and health conservation were among the extraneous variables.

Restrictions Testing

Random slice wasn’t used in any exploration since both needed colorful criteria for their tests, which would have been delicate to pierce if an arbitrary slice had been used. A disadvantage will be the absence of arbitrary slices. Other scarcities were also discovered in both studies. Several factors contributed to the disadvantage of the two-group layout, including the actors’ age, the form of delivery they had, and the quantum of weeks postpartum they were when given an opinion for PPD (Posmontier, 2008).


Chourbaji,S., Hoyer,C., Richter,S.H., Brandwein,C., Pfeiffer,N., Vogt,M.A., Gass,P. (2011). Differences in Mouse Motherly Care Geste- Is There an Inheritable Impact of the Glucocorticoid Receptor? PLoS ONE,( (4).


Posmontier,B.( 2008, September 14). Functional status issues in matters with and without postpartum depression. Recaptured from